Barry A. Fenstermaker
April 9, 2026
Share a memory
Barry A. Fenstermaker Obituary
LeRoy ~ Barry Fenstermaker, age 58, passed away on Thursday, April 9th, surrounded by his loving family. Barry was born on May 29th, 1967 to James and Barbara Fenstermaker.
He will be remembered as a very caring and devoted family man, who enjoyed being with family and friends and was always ready to lend a helping hand.
A longtime resident of LeRoy, he enjoyed cheering on the Buffalo Bills, watching Syracuse basketball, grilling, cooking, and always trying new recipes. He was always considered the life of the party. He would light up a room whenever he walked in, always ready with a joke, smart comment, or ready to pick on anyone at any time (no one was off limits). He had a personality that was bigger than life.
He will be sadly missed by his wife of 32 years, Margy (Conte) Fenstermaker; his daughters, Samantha (Zack) Reimer and Hope Fenstermaker; his father, Jim Fenstermaker; his sister, Amy (Bryan) Geedy; brother, Brent Fenstermaker; brother-in-law, Frank (Tammi) Conte; mother-in-law, Josie Conte; nieces, Brittany (Brandon) Maines, Brenna Fenstermaker, Alicia (Jake) Conte, Marissa Conte, Haley (Ryan) Conte; nephews, Travis (Brooke) Fenstermaker, Tyler (Montana) Fenstermaker, Trent (Caitlin) Fenstermaker, Jacob (Abbey) Geedy, Frankie (Kristine) Conte; great-nieces, Claire, Luella, Olivia, and Emmy Jo; great-nephews, Ivan, Julian, and Parker, along with his dog, Gunther and grand-dog, Chevy.
Barry is predeceased by his mother, Barbara Fenstermaker; his paternal grandparents, Morris and Aldine Fenstermaker; his maternal grandparents, Everett and Catherine Thrush and his father-in-law, Santo Conte.
Family and friends may call on Thursday April, 16th, from 4 – 8 PM at the Falcone Family Funeral & Cremation Service, 8700 Lake St. Rd., LeRoy.
LeRoy ~ Barry Fenstermaker, age 58, passed away on Thursday, April 9th, surrounded by his loving family. Barry was born on May 29th, 1967 to James and Barbara Fenstermaker.
He will be remembered as a very caring and devoted family man, who enjoyed being with family and friends a
Events
Visitation
Thursday, April 16, 2026
4:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Falcone Family Funeral & Cremation Service Inc.
8700 Lake Rd. (Rt 19) LeRoy, NY 14482